Exploring political and socioeconomic realities from my admittedly liberal, Catholic perspective. This is a learning/sharing endeavor: if you have comments that enrich, complicate, challenge, or refute my arguments and premises, PLEASE SHARE!!! I am not a professional economist, sociologist, or political theorist. I learn through reading, writing, and discussing, and see no value in my own ignorance.
Saturday, January 28, 2012
The Secret of My Success: Be Lazy, Have Good Parents
First, a little history. When I hit about fourth grade, I stopped doing my homework. Having been a teacher, I know that some kids do not do their homework because they do not understand it, some because they have busy after school lives and don't prioritize it, and some do not do it for the mere fact that they are lazy. I was solidly in the latter category, a trend that continued up through high school. In my defense at the time, I hated school. Thus, in all my adolescent maturity, it stood to reason that I should not be forced to do things that I do not actually enjoy doing. In addition, I was blessed with a solid capacity to memorize a great deal of information in a short period of time, and to then remember that information at least through the next day. Thus the time in high school drama class when I neglected learning my monologue until the night before - ironic, since that is something which I enjoyed, but by that time my laziness was well-ingrained.
This also made cramming for tests fairly standard, though of course I learned little. I remember once when I wrote an essay on the influence of Irish immigrants on US history, and my teacher politely accused me of plagiarism because he had never seen me display any measure of effort or competency in anything, let alone a ten-page essay. But this all begs the question: why did I even cram for tests or write essays in the first place? What prevented my laziness from taking hold entirely? Part of the answer lies in the fact that certain tasks, like writing essays, appealed to me (go figure), and that, through a more-than-decent education, I had somehow acquired the skills to do so effectively. Even more fundamentally, though, is the fact of my parents. They may not have been able to sway me from willful mediocrity (and anyone who knows kids can hardly blame them), but even I had limits, and outright failure was not an option.
Of course, I also, as many young ones do, had an outsized view of my own abilities and wisdom. In that wisdom, I decided firmly that I would not go to college. Now, in my actual defense, this was not an act of laziness. I sincerely hated school, and had visions of making it in the world of socially conscious, indy hop hop. (Hmmm...maybe not such a solid defense after all.) In any case, my parents were having none of it. They insisted that I apply at least to one college, and by some stroke of luck I got in. Moreover, they so valued education and my future that they risked paying for me to go to college, despite my previous track record with education.
It was probably the single most important that anyone ever made for me. I flourished in college: I worked hard, earned a 3.8 overall GPA, and held a job in which I was working about 30 hours a week by the time that senior year rolled around. After college, I entered a volunteer teaching program and earned my Master's in education. I do not list these accomplishments to brag - quite the opposite, it's all pretty shameful to me. Though those who know me well know that there were several other bumps along the way - loss, grief, health issues, unemployment - they also know that I am extremely happy now, work hard at job that I am blessed to have, married to a wonderful woman, and that I recently bought a house.
In short, I may be going to Hell. How can I be in this position when I so willfully avoided success for so long? Moreover, any number of circumstances may have done me in: had my parents not been able to send me to good schools, be they elementary, high school, or university; had my parents not both been well-educated and valued education; had I not been born with certain intellectual gifts that helped me skate by; had one of my parents become unemployed or died while I was young - any number of events or realities could have derailed my success. And yet, things somehow turned out this way, nonetheless.
This may be the fundamental reason, then, that I do not buy the argument that anyone in this country can succeed through a little hard work. To be clear, while laziness should have done me in, I am not arguing that I think that the poor are lazy. Instead, I am pointing out that, primarily through luck of birth, I as an entirely non-exceptional student was protected from failure and ultimately able to succeed. We make much in this country of those exceptional people that pull themselves out of poverty as an example of the justice of it all, as do we of our own hard work and the ludicrous contention that any of us are successful due only to our own work ethic. Many people work hard their entire lives and seem to get nowhere. And, increasingly, the jobs that allowed immigrant groups to rise out of poverty are disappearing.
Take the example of my wife. She grew up in circumstances very different from my own - she grew up in a steel mill town, her parents migrated from Puerto Rico, her father found a grueling but steady job in the mills. She, in my mind, is an exceptional person both in intelligence and work ethic. She was able to get into and graduate from the University of Notre Dame with both a bachelor's and master's degree. But even she was fortunate enough to be blessed with a level of economic and familial security growing up that many around her did not have. (And where are all of those steel mill jobs going?)
So, when people tell me that hard work is all it takes, I cannot help but reflect on my own good fortune, as well as the good and misfortune of those whom I have met. When I worked in Birmingham, AL, with inner-city kids, I saw that many of them had behavior problems stemming from family situations, learning challenges stemming from a poor education, developmental challenges that we their teachers were not equipped to address, family members that had been killed or arrested, anger problems that they had not learned to resolve constructively, a willingness to learn that was often disrupted by the more troubled and troublesome students in the classroom, and language and writing issues that will likely severely limit the type of employment they can find, or what colleges, if any, would take them. Not to mention, of course, economic problems that would make attending college highly unlikely.
Many of their parents would frustrate me - those that didn't seem to value education; those that encouraged their children to resolve conflicts violently. I would find myself judging these people, blaming them for their children's behavior. But once I stepped back, I was able to reflect on what types of parents that the people before must have had, what type of challenges that they must have faced growing up, what types of challenges they now face. And it is because I know that I, as a non-exceptional person, may well have been beat down by these challenges, and because I know that it is only through circumstance that I had the opportunity and skills to succeed, that I cannot merely label others as not taking full advantage of a supposed abundance of opportunity.
I have had times in my adult life in which I have fought hard to transcend my circumstances, but I was only able to do so because for so much of my youth, my circumstances transcended me. I believe that people should work hard; I encouraged my students every day to become better writers, thinkers, and people. But I recognize that for even the brightest and hardest-working among them, the fight to transcend those circumstances will be grueling, disheartening, and yes, for a good number, potentially fruitless. I believe, though, that if those of us who are more fortunate care about the people we so easily could have been, that if we learn to love, respect, and listen to these people, that if we commit to working with, serving, and learning from these people, that we can address these injustices. Not because we feel sorry for them, not because we have any secrets to success that they merely need heed, but simply because they are human beings that deserve the same opportunities that we had, and because it is right. That was another thing, by the way, that I learned from my parents: love others and do what's fair and right.
Sunday, January 22, 2012
Reimagining Excellence: Beyond Wealth and Power
For some time, the name of this yacht has bothered me. Initially, I mocked it as an almost cartoonish stereotype: I imagined the smug millionaire proudly sporting a blue blazer and starched captain’s hat as he steered his prized vessel. Whatever my motivations, this image was a cheap source of entertainment for me, based solely on my assumptions of a complete an utter stranger. I had imposed judgment on this person knowing nothing about him or her, other than that he or she owned a yacht, and had chosen to emblazon it with a phrase which, in all honesty, should be fairly inoffensive. I was reflecting upon that phrase recently, however, and what it means for my own life and society at large. We make much in my country of excellence, and how those that pursue it will reap the benefits of their noble efforts. In fact, much of our concept of freedom – economic, educational, vocational, etc. – is based largely on the notion that we as a society must protect the right of the individual to pursue excellence. Furthermore, we often argue that an excellent society will necessarily erupt when that individual freedom is ensured.
But what does excellence mean? If we fail to define it and its ramifications, then we will continually fail to understand, persuade, and cooperate with one another towards its achievement. I see this most strikingly in current debates about poverty and prevailing models of capitalism, domestically and globally. Are businesses that seek to maximize profits for shareholders, no matter the cost to employees, acting unethically, or merely answering the call to perform in an exemplary manner? Is demanding that employees work twelve hour days merely expecting an appropriately rigorous commitment to their work, or actually destroying a rigorous commitment to family and the community? How can we agree on how to design social welfare programs if we cannot express what people ought to be able to achieve and how they might do so?
I do not aim here to answer all of those questions, but instead to propose a notion of human excellence, one which guides much of my thinking on political and social matters. Let me first say that this notion is predicated and two fundamental understandings arising out of my faith: firstly, that human beings are made in the image and likeness of God, and secondly, that God is love. While this may not appeal to those of you that do not share my faith, they are fundamental to my thinking. It is also important to note that, for me, this means that even those that do not share mine or any religious faith are still constructed in this way, and are thus oriented towards love and solidarity. In a more secular vein, I can say that I believe that humans are intrinsically social, that we seek justice, and that we are most content when we live in peaceful, just, free societies centered on solidarity between all people. Based on this understanding, I would argue that the pursuit of excellence is actually the cultivation of the moral/spiritual, intellectual, and even physical self towards advancing peace, justice, and freedom rooted in the common bonds of love. I will tackle each of these categories of excellence and their ramifications in reverse order.
PHYSICAL EXCELLENCE
First, I am making explicit mention of the need for physical excellence, and the ability for citizens of a free society to pursue it. I recognize the dangers inherent to this emphasis: that we can become overly motivated by vanity or the pursuit of power. However, you cannot separate the pursuit from the end goal of fulfilling our capacity to love, nor can you separate a single area of excellence from the others or the whole. To take care of our bodies, then, through exercise, proper diet, and appropriate rest, is actually aimed at making us more able to commit ourselves to others. We are happier when we eat healthily and exercise regularly, and we are more productive and attentive to the needs of others when we are properly rested. On a sheer existential level, we are also only able to fully focus on intellectual and moral/spiritual cultivation when our basic physical needs – rest, shelter, nutrition – are met.
Of course, when we shift from pursuing physical excellence to physical perfection, we become too inwardly focused and lose sight of the overall goal. Personally, I struggle with this balance. I try to exercise for one hour three or four days a week, and to walk my dog twice daily. Too often, though, I become transfixed with critiquing my physical appearance, especially as someone that has dealt with weight issues since adolescence. The point, though, is to be healthy in a way that allows me to fulfill my capacity to love and care for others. In the recent past, an illness consumed my life, and consequently that of my wife in caring for me, eventually leading to the loss of employment and massive medical debt. Even after returning to physical health, the debt alone hindered me in the ability to be of service to others.
The social ramifications of the importance of physical excellence, then, are huge. Most Americans believe in the ability to pursue happiness as a central human right. If human happiness is at least partially dependent on physical well-being, then we need to guarantee the ability to pursue genuine physical health. This that means providing access to affordable, healthy food becomes vital to our social well-being. This means that affordable health care becomes a central right for all citizens. This means re-orienting our concept of work to prevent exhaustion and excessive time away from friends, family, and exercise. This means limiting environmental hazards in our air, water, and food supply. I think that we all would agree that it is important to encourage physical health, but we need to step back and grapple with the question of whether and how we as a society fully allow it.
INTELLECTUAL EXCELLENCE
The second area of excellence which I wish to highlight is intellectual excellence. Here, I think that the quality and purpose of that excellence may be subject to debate. People that have known me for any length of time know that I love to debate multiple subjects (sometimes, it seems, any subject). Because it is my nature to challenge, question, and contradict, I continually grapple with the challenge of abandoning argument for its own sake, and orienting myself towards uncovering truth in the pursuit of love and justice. I believe that a willingness and ability to debate are intellectual gifts with which I have been endowed and which I am responsible to pursue, both for my own health and to play a positive social function. Again, that positive social function is the critical goal, and will ultimately fulfill me in that as a human being I am naturally oriented towards serving others.
We err in highlighting and pursuing intellectual excellence for its own sake. In my case, this could mean using any knowledge or debate tactic merely to win an argument, as opposed to uncover and promote justice based in truth. For others, this may mean using leadership skills solely to amass power or wealth, social intelligence to take advantage of rather than empower others, scientific or engineering expertise to engender hate or destruction rather than peace or positive creation – the list goes on. On a societal level, the recognition of the value of true intellectual excellence to the human person and humanity itself requires that we both encourage an intelligence that is focused on the common good, and allow as many people to pursue their intellectual gifts as possible. This requires, at minimum, a truly free and fair education for all, one which helps people succeed no matter their economic, family, regional, or national situation. It requires an education system that is oriented not only towards monetary success, but deep intellectual growth. It also requires a social/work structure that allows people to cultivate and pursue their intellectual gifts. This means guaranteeing access to knowledge, forming strong community centers, and shifting radically away from the work-survive-rest expectation for individual existence, especially for those whose employment does not offer sufficient intellectual challenge and growth.
MORAL/SPIRITUAL EXCELLENCE
The final category of excellence that I am touching upon here is, in some way, notable in its absence from much of our concept of excellence. When I read the name of that yacht in Hilton Head, for instance, the idea of moral and/or spiritual excellence did not even cross my mind. Moral/spiritual excellence is more profoundly distinct, however, in that the ideal stands most firmly outside of the individual. I realize that many might balk at this claim: we often frame either moral conduct or spiritual leanings as personal – my personal values, my personal relationship with God, etc. While morality and spirituality will always be framed by personal experience and understandings, it does not negate the fact that there are non-relative rights and wrongs, nor does it negate the reality of God.
The religious claim may be easier to make. God is God, and how we ought to act in the world is necessarily defined by our being made in God’s image, not God in our own. On a strictly moral level, while acting ethically in the world is not always a clear-cut proposition, we do accept certain moral truths, such as the inherent dignity and equality of the human person, that stand as self-evident. Thus, whereas the heights of my possible physical and intellectual excellence will always be limited by my inherent capacities – I will never, for instance, play professional sports or work for NASA – moral and spiritual truths are inherent to themselves. That does not mean, however, that I can ever fully grasp them. Because we recognize our own limitations, we must recognize that we are at best moving towards moral/spiritual excellence, but remain extremely far from achieving it.
Again, it is of the utmost importance that we encourage and allow all people to pursue moral excellence, both for their own well-being and the well-being of the human race. This may at times dramatically challenge our notions of excellence itself: if I am not producing as many products as possible, working as hard as possible, earning as much money as possible, am I succeeding? The answer will vary between person and situation, because it will be contingent upon the ability of the individual to grasp and execute that answer. The key is that we need to instill the importance of asking these questions in the first place, provide a solid framework for people to engage in answering them, and to allow people to make moral decisions without undue harm.
I would argue that the social implications of this last point are massive. When people face a severe and insurmountable existential threat for acting ethically, we are not truly allowing for the pursuit of moral excellence. For instance, those who spoke out against racial segregation in the United States in the 1950’s and 1960’s were routinely beaten and killed for acting upon the moral truth of human equality. In many cases, the severity of the consequence for moral opposition was so great that many oppressed people understandably chose life and security for themselves and for their families over further violence and death. Society is charged with ensuring to the furthest possible extent that people are able to act morally without severe existential consequences. This means, for instance, that people should not have to choose between crime and basic survival. People should not have to choose between advocating for livable wages and keeping their jobs. People should not have to choose between getting the illness of a family member treated and being able to afford their rent or mortgage. Although there will always be times when people will choose to suffer excessive or even deadly consequences for a moral/spiritual stance, we have a social imperative to identify and eliminate these injustices at every turn.
CONCLUSION
We orient so much of our personal and collective lives towards excellence and the exceptional that I wanted here to engage in a discussion of what this truly means, what we truly aspire to, and what this requires of us both as individuals and as a human race. Every individual has a responsibility towards the social pursuit of excellence, and every society is charged with encouraging and allowing the individual pursuit of excellence. However, I feel that, too often, excellence is defined in terms of end gains that are not grounded in the pursuit of love, peace and justice. If we accept that a free society must ensure the ability of all of its members to freely pursue excellence, then we need to be abundantly clear about what excellence truly means.
I would argue that a system that views excellence as the endless pursuit of material gains is fundamentally misguided. In fact, I would go so far as to say that this system actually inhibits our pursuit of excellence. For those struggling economically, it forces all energy towards survival, and for those prospering economically it denies the ability of their true moral/spiritual, intellectual, and physical self to come to life. It is critical to note that I am indeed discussing a single self. Our physical well-being is prerequisite to our intellectual and moral/spiritual well-being, our intellectual well-being requires that we are morally grounded, and our moral/spiritual well-being requires strengthening our intellectual health. Of course, each individual may face limitations in certain areas, but it is vital to that individual and society that he or she be allowed to excel in each and every way to the furthest extent possible. Only then will we become truly excellent as individuals, societies, and a human family.
Sunday, January 8, 2012
A Free-Market Meritocracy? Survival of the Fortunate
With that in mind, I was considering the notion of "survival of the fittest" as an inescapable economic and social reality. Ignoring (for the moment) the question of whether a "social Darwinist" system is just, I instead want to question whether it is even practically possible for such a system to exist, especially in any lasting capacity. Specifically, the wealthy class that emerges from a free-market socio-economic model will ultimately seek to maintain that wealth by any means necessary, and be endowed with the economic, political, and social resources to do so. This devolves into a system in which nepotism, cronyism, and political collusion ensure that power and wealth are passed down between the generations and to limited social circles.
We can see this borne out intentionally when someone like James Murdoch is groomed to run his father's company, or an average-to-sub par student is admitted into Yale due to the prominence of his father. It is also evident, of course, in the social reality that economic opportunity is opened up largely through family and other social connections, whether as intentional policy or merely a natural outcome of competition. This presents the fundamental challenge to the myth of the meritocracy: as favor is given to the less-able but well-connected, those same opportunities are necessarily denied to more-able people. Some would argue that this is both an inescapable reality and inconsequential in terms of breadth of opportunity, at least in the United States. However, this tendency expands beyond immediate connections to shape large-scale social realities such as the strength of entire school districts, tax policy, regulations on certain industries, and a slew of other social and economic legislation, such that, with each passing generation, the wealthy class becomes even more solidified in its standing and wealth, to the detriment of the rest of society. For these reasons, we now face a situation where the greatest percentage of Americans is in poverty since the 1950's, while a massive amount of wealth lies firmly in the hands of a tiny percentage of Americans.
This not only debunks the myth of a lasting meritocracy, but also poses serious economic and societal challenges. Because those in power and those with wealth are largely one and the same, and those with wealth increasingly attain that wealth not through merit but through social inheritance, we find ourselves in a situation in which the leaders of our nation are increasingly not the "best and brightest," but merely the most fortunate. Considering this, as well as the earlier-mentioned tendency to protect wealth at all costs, it is perhaps not surprising that many of these same people lacked the economic foresight to avoid short-term, profitable transactions designed in such a way as to inevitably collapse. And because the fortunes of the many are so intimately tied to the decisions - and fate - of this wealthy/powerful class, its failure necessarily imperils the rest of us.
Again, although I am deeply concerned with the moral ramifications of this system, I am here only pointing out the economic consequences. Because of these inherent dangers, we need to then consider the role of government in protecting against economic collapse. It is telling that society in the United States formed to produce a democracy, and not some sort of feudal system of concentrated wealth and power. In rebelling against the crown, the colonists proclaimed a desire for economic liberty (indeed, much of the rift was due to a perceived injustice in taxation). Still, out of this came a system of government modeled on representation of the people with both local and federal authority. It is fundamental to our understanding of human life that some sort of system of governance must be formed to ensure the protection of the short- and long-term viability of the society, that this requires oversight of and, at times, direct influence upon commerce, and that the interests of all citizens should be considered, regardless of class. A democracy, especially, is designed to protect against a system in which a powerful few hold undue influence. While we have struggled to attain that ideal throughout our history, it remains the ideal, nonetheless.
This is why distracting debates over supposed "socialism" and "distribution of wealth" are so counterproductive and insidious. They allow those with wealth to present themselves as protectors of the meritocracy, as opposed to obstacles to it. Instead, we should discuss whether it is necessary to the health of our society to ensure the distribution of opportunity. This poses a number of challenges due to the ramifications: equal opportunity would require a decent education for all and an educational system that does not favor social standing, a decent living wage for all working Americans, a health care system that allows the ill and their families to avoid insurmountable debt due to medical bills and loss of work, etc.
Of course, our original national ideals already speak to the role of government in ensuring this reality, since it is fundamental to our government's mandate that it protect the right to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" of all Americans. Our current political-economic model threatens and denies those rights, imperiling the long-term survival of our society and, increasingly, the short-term survival of its citizens. Instead, the government must, at times, enact proactive and corrective measures on commerce to ensure that it does not imperil these rights for the general public. Because these measures were not in place, the government was recently left with the choice of bailing out those whom, under a true meritocracy, ought to fail due to poor decisions, or deny their fundamental mandate even further by allowing an economic collapse that would devestate its citizenry to massive effect.
The irony, of course, is that in order to protect a capitalist system, limits and modifications must by placed on it. If we allow our democratic principles to take a back seat to our meritocratic principles, we inevitably sacrifice both.
Saturday, December 10, 2011
So What If You Saved the Auto Industry?: Searching for Moral Genius
I’m growing tired of our geniuses. More pointedly, I am frustrated with a culture that lauds their natural gifts and work ethic, but fails profoundly to challenge them to the common good. We all know the typical capitalist response to this, of course. We are told over and over again that corporate and industrial ingenuity actually does serve the common good. But most arguments in this vein revolve around the supposed inevitability of the shared benefits of industry, not the intentionality of those benefits. Assuming true a straightforward – and simplistic – justification of capitalist endeavors, we are still left with the irrefutable fact that all of this social good is merely a by-product. The primary focuses of the Steve Jobs and Henry Fords (aka real American heroes) are a) to explore the limits of their own minds, and b) to make money. This is not to say that there is anything wrong with either, or even to say that we should necessarily expect all people to elevate beyond this mentality. My point here is only inherently heroic about these pursuits.
I was struck by this recently while reading an article about Sergio Marchionne, the head of Italy-based Fiat turned savior of American-born Chrysler. The article was in Time Magazine, a fact significant only because I only read that magazine when I travel (it’s a thing). I happened to be returning from the national assembly of my department, a gathering of many talented and passionate people united in a common goal of inspiring and accompanying people in the United States answer a call to good. I could not help but contrast this with Marchionne, both in the scope of his abilities (sorry, team) and the focus of his work. While sparing you the nuts and bolts (Google it, if you want), it suffices to say that via a natural propensity for leadership, an intuitive sense of what enables and engenders success in employees, and immense technical knowledge, he has been able to return a dying auto-maker to profitability.
What hit me was not the commonly held sense of admiration for the competence of men and women like Marchionne, but a strong feeling that many of the great minds of the modern age are more or less abandoning the people of this world and their needs. Yes, a small measure of jobs were saved and created by Marchionne’s actions, which is of great significance to those people that directly benefitted. But in a world in which dependence on oil negatively impacts people all of the world – from Americans paying high oil prices to the more severe reality of displaced and oppressed people in oil-rich nations (not to mention environmental impacts) – why is this man’s role in saving the auto industry so laudable to us? Why do we not ask, expect even, that someone such as this work to solve the real technical problems of moving away from an oil-based economy altogether? Why don’t we expect that people such as him help poor nations develop a reliable infrastructure to deliver drinking water to their people? While Marchionne worked to combine and increase the efficiency of Fiat and Chrysler, with each playing to the other’s weaknesses, why don’t envision him partnering struggling non-profits to more efficiently execute their mandates to generate social good? Wouldn’t it be great if we cultivated moral creativity and genius in otherwise exceptional people?
I already know that some will latch onto my earlier mention of Steve Jobs and run through all the ways that he has made modern life more convenient. Even ignoring the serious ethical questions about the Apple assembly line, I would challenge anyone to convince me that this was the extent of the impact that Steve Jobs could have had in making this world a truly better place. I do not mean to disparage Jobs, or even Marchionne. Boundless though their abilities may seem, they are still limited by a culture that lacks the will to expect boundless love, compassion, and moral imagination from our heroes and leaders. Yes, sometimes good does, indeed, “trickle down” from their efforts. And sometimes, even, these people spend some small amount of money and energy on charitable works, but is this really an acceptable standard for our heroes? I, for one, find more to admire in the small successes of a group of committed social-servants than the grand enterprises of the hyper-intelligent masters of industry. Especially considering that we are, in many cases, talking about people with a clear vision for the future and a dedication to executing that vision. Wouldn’t it be great if we said to them, “What is your vision for a more just and peaceful world?” – and not as a by-product or side-project, but as a life project. Of course, that would require that we as a people place enough value on such efforts to motivate, inspire, and support our heroes. Because just as children grow to emulate the values of their parents, we shape our leaders as much or more than they shape us.
Wednesday, December 7, 2011
Promises, Promises: OWS, Corporate America, and Taking the Long View
One of the persistent (though not necessarily widespread) opinions of OWS was that it consisted of lazy, spoiled young people who feel entitled to a quick, easy road to success. Ironically, this view is espoused often by members of the generation that actually raised these young people, promising them, at base, a quick, easy road to success. And this is where I think that things get more complicated than we have tended to make them. I do not view the people engaged in OWS with any of the pejoratives mentioned. A promise has been made. That promise, that in this nation, hard work and education necessarily breed success, is simply and profoundly false. Many of us knew this previously, of course, for example some of us that are members of or have worked with low-income communities. Now, however, those limitations have been laid out for all of us to see – even if we may still choose not to do so. Much of OWS, then, is a belated sense of the injustice of the system, propelled by the natural shock of a shattered belief system. We can at least credit them with looking truth in the face and accepting it, something which many of their critics are unwilling or unable to do. This, of course, makes a certain degree of sense. Though false, this promise is deep-seated and perpetuated almost universally across the social spectrum.
In the past, the perpetuation of this false promise could be argued to, at the very least, protect the existing power structure. If we all believe that everyone has a fair shot, that we can all be successful with a little elbow grease, and that consumerism will, in the end, lead to happiness, then those at the highest tier of the social order can maintain and prosper unperturbed. Recent events, however, have exposed a fatal flaw in this mentality: its utter lack of longevity. Specifically, you cannot maintain the illusion of social mobility while at the same time eviscerating the middle class. And you can’t achieve and maintain maximum amounts of immediate profits without eviscerating the middle class – jobs must be shed to protect bottom lines and executive bonuses. Moreover, you cannot maintain an industry over the long-term while at the same time all but eliminating a vital, creative workforce. That would seem like common-sense: when all you have left is people concerned about making money and none of the people driven and qualified to make anything else, then you no longer have anything to offer. And, of course, you cannot do any of this and maintain a healthy society and competitive economy.
At this point, it may seem like I am being overly-harsh on the business community. A few clarifications: one, not all business is created equal. This has been one of the best-executed distortions by the corporate world: that to challenge any for-profit enterprise is to challenge every for profit enterprise, period. So first, let us at least come to a common understanding: most businesses exist to earn profit. I know that some will use that statement as a criticism, while others will use it as an absolution. I am not assigning any editorial value. The key is that some businesses earn their profits in ways that add value to our society (i.e.: through employment, ingenuity, solving problems) while others do not (i.e.: they do not employ or do not employ in the US, they exploit resources, they harm the environment, they create rather than solve problems). Ironically, those most concerned with immediate financial gain are both more likely to fall into the latter category and, by virtue of that financial success, receive favorable policy treatment.
A second clarification: in the interest of the big picture, I am attempting to focus on what I see as a largely neglected piece of the national conversation. Much has been discussed of American values and habits on the low- and middle-income levels. Specifically, the tendency of people towards consumerism, debt, and the urge to make a quick buck (even though, in regards to this last point, Americans work longer, more, and more productively than almost any other industrialized nation). So yes, consumerism (and the debt it accrues) is a societal problem. But the emphasis is on societal, as in, across society. For one thing, as I hope that I have illuminated, much of our corporate and (I’ll go this far here) business culture in general is extremely short-sighted in terms of hiring and ingenuity. Admittedly, for small and mid-sized businesses this is often simply an existential reality – they need to be short-sighted in order to survive. For larger corporations it is harder to make that claim, at least when they are consistently increasing executive salaries.
Similarly, our politicians are short-sighted in catering to these interests. It is virtually impossible to run a successful political campaign, at least beyond the local level, without significant corporate backing. This may seem to cater towards the existential reality argument, but whereas businesses have the option of serving the common good, politicians have a mandate. In any case, this is why President Obama is not the anti-business Socialist that many conservatives pretend he is and that many liberals thought he would be. In fact, he has reduced and eliminated more business regulations than President George W. Bush. This is not a defense of Obama (quite the contrary), but merely helps to illustrate my point that there is about a snowball’s chance in Hell of a truly anti-business candidate being elected president. The short-sighted piece, of course, is evident in the trouble that Obama faces not for being too liberal, but for failing to be the president that he promised to be.
Finally, there is the tricky matter of our economy itself, which, in our short-sightedness, we have ingeniously constructed to run on our own short-sighted nature. We condemn those greedy fools that bought houses that they couldn’t afford, yet lament the continuously weak housing market. We wag our finger at all that accumulated debt, yet bend over backwards to incentivize Americans to spend more and (yes, this has actually been said explicitly by economists) stop saving. In the meantime, we have a contingent of people urging the US Government to start saving and eliminate deficits at a time when, economically, it makes most sense to spend money to get people back to work and get the economy moving again. But then, we’re told that this would be short-sighted.
What we need, then, is to re-orient ourselves towards the true American promise. Rather than cling to myths about what our country is, why not work to make it what we want? If we say that all people have the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, why not re-orient ourselves towards addressing these rights? Why not first ask ourselves what these things mean – What does a full right to life entail? What does genuine liberty look like? What will make us happy? – and how we can ensure the actualization of each? Instead of believing in false promises, we should do the hard work of fulfilling those promises that ought to be true.
Thursday, September 2, 2010
Peanuts at Ground Zero (Or Some Such Nonsense)
Here’s a question: how do you get US citizens to care about the world’s problems when they don’t seem to even care about their own? The article “The Peanut Solution,” out in the New York Times on Tuesday, September 2, 2010, tells the story of “Plumpy’nut,” a nutrient-rich peanut butter paste that has shown immense potential for combating malnourishment in developing nations. The article also examines the corporate fight over the right to generate and distribute – and thus, profit from – this easy-to-produce product. Although apparently developed by a physician with little interest in financial incentives, a company by the name of Nutriset holds the patent. According to the article, this company is currently denying developing nations the right to manufacture this product, instead working to secure a monopoly on nutrition. These nations are, of course, in desperate need of means to combat food shortages. Admittedly, the issue is nuanced, and deals with corporate incentives to develop products of value to the poor, as well as crucial questions about the nature in which corporate interests can commandeer the treatment of disease and malnourishment. Still, by objective standards, the exploitation of the poor, sick, and dying for financial gains should cause an international outcry – or at least interest. Whether this comes to pass remains to be seen. I, however, have a sneaking suspicion that it will somehow fail to garner much national attention here in the US. For one thing, it is difficult to generate a sexy title for the situation, preferably one that preys on both our fears and biases (Ground Zero Mosque, anyone?). Even the article itself, written by Andrew Rice, uses the word “solution” right in the title, as if the notion of actually solving a problem appeals to anyone these days. What’s worse, the word is paired with one that conjures images of a monocle-sporting cartoon character. Still, even if the proper adjustments were made – perhaps “Poverty Peddlers” or “Can Peanut Butter Kill?” – I find it difficult to believe that this story would generate broad public interest. Sadly, we seem stubbornly indifferent to the global issues that truly impact people’s lives, even our own.
.Take, for example, the BP oil spill. While the cable news media drooled all over themselves covering the disaster, most of them seemed truly disinterested in the complex causes and implications. Most of discussion instead revolved around human interest stories and how much BP would pay in damages. While important stories in their own right, their prominence speaks to a trend in the media to oversimplify the broader issues and neglect long-term examination. This tendency applies to us as well. Even if you did sit glued to the television set every night, following the coverage and adding little snippets of information to your “Obama Sucks” Facebook page or “It’s All Bush’s Fault” blog, you likely have since moved on from the discussion. Now, though, is exactly when we should take a look at the steps needed to prevent such tragedies in the future. In the wake of the spill, I hear very few Americans talking about the loosening of government oversight, the carte blanche approach to corporate practices, or our dependence on an energy source that is both finite and highly volatile. In fact, I hear very little talk of the spill itself anymore, despite the fact that the Gulf waters remain saturated with pollution, threatening not only lives, but industry in an already much-weakened economy. In the public imagination, it seems, all of these things pose less of a threat than, let’s say, a cultural center in New York to serve Muslims that already lived there in the first place.
.
Of course, perhaps the issue most firmly on the collective mind at present is unemployment. While complain about the government’s inability to magically create jobs, we largely ignore the deep-seated factors contributing to not only to the shrinking job market, but to the decline of a genuine middle-class. It’s no secret that current job growth is highly concentrated at two opposite ends of the employment spectrum. At one end, high-wage employment is rebounding, and at that the other we see an uptick in low-income employment. Middle-income employment is, well, middling, and many formerly white- and blue-collar workers can only find work in minimum wage, service sector jobs, if at all. Tempting as it is to view this as a temporary by-product of the struggling economy, in actuality it is the acceleration of a long-term trend. As a nation, we decided slowly and steadily to promote short-sighted financial growth over long-term economic resilience and stability. In doing so, we greased the rails for the current crisis.
.In gutting the manufacturing sector, for instance, we have eliminated a key path to inter-generational success. We still cling to the “pull yourself up by your bootstraps,” American Dream mentality, even though we have steadily removed wrung after wrung of the social ladder. Traditionally, factory jobs provided a relatively comfortable, steady income which allowed people to care for their families. It also allowed many people to send their children to college, and thus improve the economic prospects for that next generation. As corporate profits became a national priority, though, the US shifted from primarily exporting manufacturing goods to the export of raw materials. This not only resulted in companies displacing the local markets of many developing nations, but also devastated a cornerstone of our economy, not to mention society as a whole. Now, the government focuses on stimulus plans that encourage us to spend money that we ought to save, because our economy depends disproportionately on consumerism. Each month, the economic reports lament the continually high savings rate of the US population as an impediment to growth. We live in a system that actively discourages frugality, thrift, and far-sightedness, and encourages us to live on credit. In fact, it in many ways demands it, which contributed largely to the housing bubble. Many will blame working- and middle-class consumers for entering into loans that they no longer could afford to pay, but fail to acknowledge the benefits that this inflated housing market rendered onto the rest of us. Furthermore, as a nation we buy into the myth of job security for the middle-class, meaning that when we enter into such loans, we actually believe that we can pay them off. Only later, when we are blindsided by layoffs, does home ownership become a liability. This system, then, harms the future prospects of not only those at the bottom, but basically anyone not at or near the top.
.
And still, we do not really talk about this, at least not in any dynamic, socio-economic terms. Sure, you might hear discussions of these issues on NPR or read the discourse in the New Yorker or the Economist, but regular people seem to subscribe to the notion that still, despite all the ways in which our economic reality has fundamentally shifted over the years to the detriment of the populous, the old formula of hard work necessarily equals success still applies (whether it ever truly applied is another issue entirely). We ask for our jobs to come back, but do not look at what needs to change for that to happen. We criticize government regulation as unpatriotic and anti- capitalist, but still want those deregulated industries to provide us the higher wages and health benefits that they do not have to provide in the developing world. It’s no wonder, then, that we seem none too interested in peanut-paste saving lives in Africa. We seem to care so little not only about our less fortunate neighbors, but even about our own precarious state. So many of the people struggling now to make ends meat held solidly middle-class jobs only a few years ago. Most of us live paycheck-to-paycheck without even realizing it, until someone pulls the rug out from under us. Naturally, we want that rug back, but neglect to even examine why it was so poorly secured to the floor, let alone amend the problem.Thursday, October 29, 2009
Former “Cheers” regular George Wendt has released a new memoir, “Drinking With George.” Check out these other titles by George Wendt:
Where It All Wendt: A journey through the rise and fall of sex icon George Wendt
Money Well Wendt: George’s guide to sound investing
Hell Wendt on Raising Hell: How the character “Norm” subversively spawned a new era of rebellion and debauchery
I Want You to Wendt Me: George spends a year on the road with Cheap Trick
The Wendt in the Willows: George discovers the joys of outdoor nudity
You Wendt Some, You Lose Some: George gambles away his savings and loves every minute of it.
Heaven Wendt: A heartfelt account of one man’s path to God
I Wendt It When I Said It: George’s guide to disciplined parenting
Enough is Enough - Learning When to Say “Wendt”: George’s top-rated weight-loss regimen
Criminal In-Wendt: George goes undercover in one of America’s most notorious prisons